HR Consultant vs. HR Manager: What Are Differences?

Table of Contents

Human resources (HR) are crucial in managing employees and fostering a productive work environment in business. HR professionals, such as HR consultants and managers, are essential to achieving these goals.

This informative and friendly blog post will explore HR Consultant vs. HR Manager, helping you understand their roles, income ranges, and when to outsource HR functions.

So let’s dive right in!

Key Takeaways

  • Human resources consultant typically works for consulting firm or independently, offering expert advice on various HR functions.
  • A single organization employs HR managers and oversees its HR functions and the internal HR team.
  • The primary differences between HR consultants and managers include their roles, responsibilities, and approaches to problem-solving.

Responsibilities of HR Consultants

HR consultants are specialized professionals who typically work for HR consulting firms or run independent businesses. Their primary role is to advise and guide organizations on various HR functions, such as talent acquisition, training and development, employee relations, and performance management.

Advising on Talent Acquisition

One of the essential responsibilities of HR consultants is guiding organizations in the process of talent acquisition.

These professionals offer valuable advice on how to find, attract, and hire the best employees for your company. They can help you create an effective recruitment strategy, screen candidates, and set up interviews to ensure you bring the right people on board.

Supporting Training and Development

Another crucial responsibility of HR consultants is assisting organizations with employee training and development. The HR professional can identify gaps in your current training programs and recommend new ones to ensure employees have the skills they need to succeed.

HR consultants can also help you create personalized strategic planning for your team members so they continue to grow and contribute positively to your company’s success.


Enhancing Employee Relations and Performance Management

Lastly, HR consultants are vital in improving employee relations and performance management. They can analyze your organization’s current practices and offer insights on creating a positive work environment where employees feel valued and engaged.

Moreover, HR consultants can recommend effective performance management strategies that help you set clear expectations, provide regular feedback, and motivate your team to achieve their best.

Responsibilities of HR Managers

On the other hand, HR managers are internal HR professionals responsible for overseeing the HR function of their organizations.

They work closely with other internal team members, such as HR generalists and HR specialists, to implement and manage HR policies and practices.

Ensuring Compliance with Labor Laws and Regulations

HR managers’ critical responsibilities are ensuring their organization follows all labor laws and regulations. This involves staying up-to-date with the latest changes in employment legislation and implementing necessary updates to company policies.

HR managers ensure compliance by ensuring compliance by protecting their organization from legal issues, fines, and even lawsuits.

Managing Employee Benefits and Compensation

Another essential duty of HR managers is overseeing employee benefits and compensation.

They work closely with other HR professionals to design competitive benefits packages and fair compensation structures that attract and retain top talent.

This job includes managing everything from health insurance and retirement plans to bonuses and salary adjustments.

By expertly handling benefits and compensation, HR managers play a crucial role in keeping employees happy and motivated.

Fostering a Positive Work Environment

HR managers are also responsible for creating and maintaining a positive work environment. This role involves addressing employee concerns, mediating conflicts, and promoting a healthy work-life balance.

They might organize team-building activities, offer flexible work arrangements, or develop employee wellness programs.

By fostering a positive atmosphere, HR managers help improve employee morale, increase job satisfaction, and ultimately contribute to the organization’s overall success.


What Are The Differences Between HR Consultants and HR Managers

HR consultants and managers work in human resources but have distinct roles and responsibilities. Here are some differences between a human resource consultant and a manager:

HR Consultants:

  • Offer expert advice and recommendations on specific HR issues.
  • Often work with multiple clients simultaneously.
  • Operate on a project-by-project basis, working with various businesses (from small startups to large corporations).
  • Provide fresh perspectives and innovative solutions to HR problems.

HR Managers:

  • Employed by a single organization, overseeing its HR functions and managing the internal HR team.
  • Focus on the long-term growth and development of their organization’s human capital.
  • Involved in day-to-day operations, such as handling employee relations and performance management.
  • Aim to maintain consistency and continuity within their organization’s HR policies and practices.

Income Range Between HR Consultant and HR Manager

Did you know that the income range for HR consultants and managers can vary quite a bit? Factors like experience, location, industry, and company size all play a part. Let me break it down for you in a simple and friendly way!

On average, HR consultants usually earn a bit more money than HR managers because their work is specialized, and they can charge clients on a project-by-project basis.

According to Comparably, as of March 28, 2023, the average HR Consultant in the US makes $108,693. Meanwhile, the average HR Manager’s salary in the US is $115,441. However, the HR managers’ range typically falls between $102,285 and $129,959.

While HR Manager might make more money on average, Internal HR manager often enjoys extra perks like health insurance and retirement plans, which consultants might not have.


Do I Need To Outsource HR Functions?

Outsourcing HR functions can be a strategic decision for small businesses that may not have the resources to maintain a full-time internal HR team.

Outsourcing can provide access to experienced HR consultancy, which can help manage complex HR issues, ensure compliance with labor laws, and develop policies and procedures that support business goals.

However, outsourcing may not be the right solution for every organization. Some businesses may prefer to maintain an internal HR team, particularly if they have unique needs or require a more hands-on approach to managing their employees.

To determine whether outsourcing HR functions is right for your business, consider your organization’s size, budget, and the complexity of your HR needs.

Consult with other HR professionals or business leaders who have experience with both outsourcing and internal HR management to weigh the pros and cons.


Considering Pros and Cons of HR Consultants

Before deciding to engage the services of an HR consultant, you need to consider the pros and cons of this approach.


  • Access to specialized expertise: HR consultants often have extensive knowledge and experience in specific areas of human resource management, enabling them to provide expert advice and guidance.
  • Fresh perspective: HR consultants can offer unbiased insights and recommendations that may not be readily available within your internal team.
  • Flexibility: Outsourcing HR functions allows your organization to access HR expertise as needed without the commitment of hiring a full-time employee.
  • Cost-effectiveness: Outsourcing HR functions can be more cost-effective for small businesses, as they only pay for their needed services.


  • Loss of control: Outsourcing HR functions can sometimes result in losing control over certain aspects of HR management, such as employee training and development.
  • Lack of continuity: HR consultants may not have a deep understanding of your organization’s culture, values, and long-term goals, which can impact the effectiveness of their recommendations.
  • Potential for miscommunication: Working with an external consultant can lead to misunderstandings or miscommunication if clear expectations and lines of communication are not established.
  • Costs: While outsourcing HR functions can be cost-effective in some cases, hiring an HR consultant for an extended period can become expensive.

In Conclusion

HR consultants and managers play vital roles in the human resources field, but their responsibilities and approaches to problem-solving can differ significantly.

While HR consultants provide specialized expertise and advice on specific HR issues, HR managers are responsible for overseeing the day-to-day HR functions within an organization.

Subscribe to Our Blog.

Stay up-to-date with the latest accounting tips and industrial news